
Devoluion and the missing link: what role for local authorities?”
As the Government sets out its plans for devolution, what do they mean for the places and communities they are intended to benefit?
In the latest IPM Member blog, Ian Cruise, an Economic and Development practitioner reflects on his experience as a Birmingham city councillor and the city’s approach to devolving power across city regions, local authorities and neighbourhoods. He asks whether the current focus on mayoral strategic authorities gives enough attention to the local knowledge, relationships and leadership that councils can bring – and invites IPM members and place practitioners to share their views.
I’ve been following with interest the announcements from Westminster about all things devolution. The Burnham Government’s Rewiring the State agenda, where Mayoral Strategic Authorities will get further responsibilities and budgets and a shift of tax raising powers through fiscal devolution is welcomed. As is the decentralisation of responsibilities to Local Authorities through double devolution.
As we are all aware, devolution isn’t a new concept. But the pace of devolution to has been extremely slow to say the least. For years, Government has drip-fed responsibilities and budgets from Whitehall to the nations and regions. All the talk of devolution takes me back to my days as a Councillor at Birmingham City Council. In 2013, Birmingham City Council began developing a new model for “city government”, that recognised cities must be governed at three different levels through a “triple devolution” model to city regions, cities and neighbourhoods. The tripe devolution model ensured that local government was a key partner.
The Council also realised that Ward Councillors, local organisations and communities should be give given a far greater role in how the city was governed and how services were delivered. District committees consisting of the 12 Councillors in the constituency received budgets to support local strategic projects and oversaw the delivery of local services. Ward committees of the 3 ward Councillors, supported by a ward advisory board that included local residents, and a Council Ward Support Officer awarded grants to local groups for projects that enhanced the local area. Housing Liaison Boards formed of Councillors, stakeholders and council tenants ensured housing performance (voids, repairs etc.) were monitored and key performance indicators met. In January 2014, Birmingham submitted this model as evidence to the Department of Communities and Local Government (Now MHCLG) inquiry on fiscal and financial devolution.
The recently released roadmap for fiscal devolution, places a large emphasis on “double devolution”. While double devolution has similarities with the model developed by Birmingham City Council in 2013, its main focus is on devolving powers and resources to Mayoral Strategic Authorities (MSA’s). For me, this leaves fundamental questions unanswered. How will communities access and benefit from this newly shifted power, and what role will local government play in connecting them to it.
While MSA’s have some local knowledge, they don’t have the hyperlocal expertise of a Local Authority. Nor do MSA’s have the hyperlocal partnerships or connections fostered through Councillors and Council Officers with local businesses, community groups, the voluntary and community sector, residents associations, health partners etc. From a place first perspective, double devolution directly from MSAs to communities will, in my opinion skip an important partner in the delivery of place first programmes. And while the fiscal devolution roadmap delivery is imminent, there is still an opportunity for Local Authorities to ensure they aren’t leapfrogged through a Memorandum of Understanding between them and the MSA.
All of the above still raises questions.
- Is it worth getting bogged down by terminology – double devolution v triple devolution?
- Is there a real difference? Is there too much emphasis on MSA’s?
- Will double devolution from MSA’s directly to communities exclude a key partner with local knowledge and connections?
- Should Local Authorities ask explicitly for a Memorandum of Understanding to stop being bypassed?
I’m keen to hear the thoughts and observations of IPM members and place practitioners on the questions above. You can share your thoughts on Ian’s points via ipm@mmu.ac.uk and can connect with Ian on LinkedIn via: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ian-cruise-mied-mipm-09264039/.
